Preventing HIV/AIDS, Other STIs, and Teen Pregnancy: Group-Based Abstinence Education Interventions for Adolescents
Abstinence education (AE) interventions promote abstinence from sexual activity (either delayed initiation or abstinence until marriage) and mention condoms or other birth control methods only to highlight their failure rates if at all. These interventions usually include messages about the psychological and health benefits of abstinence and could also include other components, such as media campaigns and community service events.
This review evaluated AE interventions delivered in school or community settings to groups of adolescents (10–19 years old), and most adhered to eight federal guidelines that were required to obtain federal funding (the Federal A-H guidelines).
Summary of Task Force Recommendations and Findings
The Community Preventive Services Task Force finds insufficient evidence to determine the effectiveness of group-based abstinence education interventions delivered to adolescents to prevent pregnancy, HIV and other sexually transmitted infections (STIs). Evidence is considered insufficient because of inconsistent results across studies.
About the Intervention
Interventions may be:
- Targeted to adolescents
- Girls only
- Boys only
- Girls and boys together
- Delivered in group settings in schools or communities
- Led by adult or peer educators
- Implemented as single or multicomponent programs
- Tailored to groups or individuals
Content of these interventions may address prevention of:
- HIV and STIs
Results from the Systematic Review
Twenty-one studies with 23 study arms qualified for analysis in this review. The meta-analyses found the following results for primary outcomes:
- Sexual activity: decrease of approximately 16% (odds ratio [OR]=0.81, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.70, 0.94; 21 study arms)
- This decrease is statistically significant, however, effect estimates differed by study design with larger effects for nonrandomized controlled trials compared to randomized controlled trials.
- Studies with both designs had problems such as differences in follow-up time and multiple studies conducted by the same investigators.
- Frequency of sex OR=0.77, 95% CI 0.57, 1.04 ( 5 study arms)
- This result, although in the favorable direction (decrease in frequency), is statistically nonsignificant. Also, effect estimates differed by study design with larger effects for nonrandomized controlled trials compared to randomized controlled trials.
- STIs: increase of approximately 8% that was statistically nonsignificant (OR=1.08, 95% CI 0.90, 1.29; 9 study arms)
- Pregnancy: increase of approximately 12% (OR=1.15, 1.00, 1.32; 10 study arms)
- Although this increase is statistically significant, sensitivity analyses suggest that the effect estimate is unreliable.
- AE had no meaningful effect on any of the following secondary outcomes:
- Number of sexual partners
- Use of protection
- Unprotected sexual activity
- In two of the studies, at least one relevant outcome was reported that could not be included in the meta-analysis because of too little information to calculate an odds ratio. The results for these studies were consistent with the results of the meta-analysis.
These reviews were based on a systematic review of all available studies, conducted on behalf of the Task Force by a team of specialists in systematic review methods, and in research, practice and policy related to adolescent sexual behavior.
An economic review was not conducted because the Task Force found insufficient evidence to determine the intervention's effectiveness.
- Analytic Framework* – see Figure 1 on page 276 [PDF - 886 kB]
- Evidence Gaps
- Summary Evidence Table* [PDF - 106 kB]
- Included Studies
- Search Strategy
Chin HB, Sipe TA, Elder RW, Mercer SL, Chattopadhyay SK, Jacob V, Wethington HR, Kirby D, Elliston DB, Griffith M, Chuke SO, Briss SC, Ericksen I, Galbraith JS, Herbst JH, Johnson RL, Kraft JM, Noar SM, Romero LM, Santelli J, Community Preventive Services Task Force. The effectiveness of group-based comprehensive risk-reduction and abstinence education interventions to prevent or reduce the risk of adolescent pregnancy, Human Immunodeficiency Virus, and sexually transmitted infections: two systematic reviews for the Guide to Community Preventive Services. [PDF - 886 kB] Am J Prev Med 2012;42(3):272-94.
Sipe TA, Chin HB, Elder RW, Mercer SL, Chattopadhyay SK, Jacob V, Community Preventive Services Task Force. Methods for conducting Community Guide systematic reviews of evidence on effectiveness and economic efficiency of group-based behavioral interventions to prevent adolescent pregnancy, Human Immunodeficiency Virus, and other sexually transmitted infections: comprehensive risk reduction and abstinence education. [PDF - 253 kB] Am J Prev Med 2012;42(3):295-303.
Community Preventive Services Task Force. Recommendations for group-based behavioral interventions to prevent adolescent pregnancy, Human Immunodeficiency Virus, and other sexually transmitted infections: comprehensive risk reduction and abstinence education. [PDF - 77 kB] Am J Prev Med 2012;42(3):304-7.
Barbot O. Getting our heads out of the sand: using evidence to make systemwide changes. [PDF - 52 kB] Am J Prev Med 2012;42(3):311-12.
Weed SE. Sex education programs for schools still in question: a commentary on meta-analysis. [PDF - 64 kB] Am J Prev Med 2012;42(3):313-15.
Wiley DC. Using science to improve the sexual health of America’s youth. [PDF - 64 kB] Am J Prev Med 2012;42(3):308-10.
Read other Community Guide publications about Preventing HIV/AIDS, Other STIs, and Teen Pregnancy in our library.
*PDF includes all of the information available and will not be updated.
The findings and conclusions on this page are those of the Community Preventive Services Task Force and do not necessarily represent those of CDC. Task Force evidence-based recommendations are not mandates for compliance or spending. Instead, they provide information and options for decision makers and stakeholders to consider when determining which programs, services, and policies best meet the needs, preferences, available resources, and constraints of their constituents.
The content of publications of the Guide to Community Preventive Services is in the public domain. Citation as to source, however, is appreciated. Sample citation: Guide to Community Preventive Services. Preventing HIV/AIDS, other STIs, and teen pregnancy: group-based abstinence education interventions for adolescents. www.thecommunityguide.org/hiv/abstinence_ed.html. Last updated: MM/DD/YYYY.
Review completed: June 2009
- Page last reviewed: May 9, 2014
- Page last updated: May 9, 2014
- Content source: The Guide to Community Preventive Services